Page 1 of 1
ThumbJam with OSCulator - MIDI note mapping
Posted: Sat Apr 09, 2011 10:02 pm
I'm having some trouble getting the note values from OSC messages to map to MIDI notes in OSCulator. According to the TJ documentation, the first parameter of the /tj/#/note message contains the "midi note number of the pitch" - I assume this is in the range 0-127. OSC messages are normally in the range 0.0-1.0 so I'm trying to use the "Scaling Page" to create proper MIDI notes.
The problem seems to be that, well, frankly, I can't work out the correct mapping. I've tried setting the Input Max to 127, while keeping the Output Max at 1.0, and I've also tried setting the Output Max to 127 (but that caused the MIDI note pitch to go nuts). I've tried a lot of different settings and I'm not able to get anything that works properly.
The closest I've got is to set Input Min to 0, Input Max to 24, but this seems to be about four octaves too high, so that C0 maps to C4.
Secondly, I've noticed that although TJ is set to *not* send pitchbend, it seems to be sending multiple note-on messages when I tilt my iPhone. This means that any slight movement of the iPhone causes multiple note-on MIDI messages to be sent to my synth.
Has anyone had any success configuring TJ with OSCulator/OSC? I had a play with DSMIDI too, and that seemed to work, although it had the same retriggering problem as mentioned above.
Actually, I think the
Posted: Sat Apr 09, 2011 10:20 pm
Actually, I think the documentation is wrong, TJ does actually output 0.0 -> 1.0. I've attached an example OSCulator patch that should work for you as an example.
[EDIT] Nevermind, it was right before!
Hi Jesse, thank you for your
Posted: Sun Apr 10, 2011 1:53 am
Hi Jesse, thank you for your reply.
Your patch is very similar to one I had, before I started messing with the MIDI note mappings. Unfortunately it does not seem to map correctly.
According to the OSCulator documentation, I can use:
defaults write net.osculator.OSCulator LogDomains -dict-add 'MIDI Notes' YES
to enable MIDI note debugging. So I did this, and when I run OSCulator from the command line it tells me what MIDI note value each OSC input produces. It gives me output like:
2011-04-10 17:45:41.683 OSCulator[7011:903] 0x200353380: MIDI Note ON: 232 (vel:127) [ch:1]
2011-04-10 17:45:42.297 OSCulator[7011:903] 0x200353380: MIDI Note OFF: 232 (vel: 0, prev pitch:232) [ch:1]
So I can tell you that with your patch I get the following mappings from ThumbJam to MIDI Note:
(and so on)
There appears to be two interleaved sequences here - but both are decreasing as the note goes *up*, and the higher values are too high for my synth (Reason) to play.
It almost looks like the values are wrapping around so that they 'alias' as a descending instead of ascending sequence.
I tried swapping min & max in OSCulator (so it goes from 1.0-0.0 instead of 0.0-1.0), and now there are still two distinct sequences, but at least they go 'up' in the right direction. G3 in TJ maps to F#2 however, so it's still no good.
I'm willing to help sort this out so if you have any ideas let me know and I'll give them a try
Actually, it was right
Posted: Sun Apr 10, 2011 8:29 pm
Actually, it was right before, the first parameter was indeed midi note number. All I had to do in the Scaling page in osculator was to set the input maximum to 127. The attached osculator patch works correctly for me.
Ok, now I'm confused! Your
Posted: Mon Apr 11, 2011 7:22 am
Ok, now I'm confused! Your patch works for me too, but it looks almost identical to mine - and mine definitely does *not* work. I hear sounds, but several 'regions' in TJ result in the same MIDI note being generated. Other than the Console Log, I can't see what is different between our two patches!
Also, although yours works properly for MIDI mapping, I get a lot of retriggers coming through even when I'm holding a note and not moving my finger, which makes it a little bit difficult to use. Do you see/hear a similar thing? It seems to be related to the accelerometer, as if I slightly tilt the iPhone (note that I have TJ set to *not* send PitchBend info) it sends new note-on messages and I get a stuttering effect.
I also get a stuttering effect if I drag between notes in TJ.
Edit: ah, I've just realised that this happens if I'm using a custom instrument that I created myself - in this case a 'silent' instrument with no samples. If I use one of the stock instruments, this stuttering goes away. A clue perhaps?
Thank you very much for the patch however - it's great that it works, I'll definitely use it. I'm just really astonished that yours works and mine does not! Am I missing something really obvious?
Unfortunately, the file
Posted: Mon Apr 11, 2011 9:27 pm
Unfortunately, the file inside the zip appears corrupt so I can't compare it. All I did was go to the View Menu->Scalings Page, and set the In Max parameter for the 0th parameter of the note message to 127.0.
Corrupt? Hmm, I just
Posted: Tue Apr 12, 2011 4:14 pm
Corrupt? Hmm, I just downloaded it and unzipped it and it opens in OSCulator fine. Strange.
I'm not sure the zip file is
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2011 4:34 pm
I'm not sure the zip file is corrupt, can you try downloading it again please? I've been communicating with the OSCulator author here:
http://www.osculator.net/forum/threads/ ... -available
There was no problem with the zip file there.
Can you please tell me which version of OSCulator you used to create the patch that you posted? It seems possible that when I create the same patch with OSCulator 220.127.116.11, it doesn't work properly at all, and yet your patch works fine.
Would be great to get to the bottom of this, as I hope to use ThumbJam via OSC in a new project soon.
Just to be complete, this was
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 9:28 pm
Just to be complete, this was finally resolved here:
http://www.osculator.net/forum/threads/ ... 1#post6333
(except for the odd missing notes, even with ad-hoc WiFi)